
Every year that I sit down to compile this list I find the method to my madness more and more inscrutable. This year more so than ever I cut albums that I knew were amazing, albums that I absolutely delighted in, because of a downright ambiguous feeling that they just didn't belong.
But I'm strangely happy with this. I cut albums from this list that I believed would be certain inclusions all year long (Bon Iver) and ones that feature songwriting so much better than some of the albums I did include (Strange Mercy, St. Vincent) that I have to shake my head at myself. Yet, I feel like it's in the true spirit of music. We never know what songs will call out to us when we hear them, touching down on some part of the heart that needed to sing.
10) Little Hell, City and Colour - The overall tone of acquiescent melancholy and longing on this album is so well-maintained that it becomes the simplest of tasks to sink into it and let it wrap around you. There is much love in Little Hell and repeated listens will bring you "cold December snow and warm July sun" both in good measure.
Northern Wind - City and Colour
9) Circuital, My Morning Jacket - I know that life is good because MMJ continues to make records that make you want to gather your friends and have adventures to. Songs like "First Light" and "Holdin' On to Black Metal" make me know I've still got a whole lotta spirit in me and that is a good, good feeling.
First Light - My Morning Jacket
8) Let England Shake, PJ Harvey - How can such a sweet voice pack such an incredible punch? PJ Harvey is a diamond blade polished to a fine and deadly point and what she has to say in this politically-charged album feels vitally important. This album contains my absolute favorite song of the year, "The Last Living Rose" but it has soft, quiet gems like this, too. A remarkable work.
Hanging In The Wire - PJ Harvey
7) Cults, Cults - The instant the first track on this record comes on I'm instantly transported to a more innocent time and place, where first heartaches swallow up your whole world and big life lessons are being learned. This album is utterly charming and unique.
Oh My God - Cults
6) Conatus, Zola Jesus - Dear gods, this album has such a big and sweeping sound, and I am completely enthralled by it. The sound space and the emotional territory it occupies is enormous. I feel as if I'm just starting to understand the breadth and depth of it and every time I listen I think, I have got to start living like this.
Skin - Zola Jesus
5) It's a Corporate World, Dale Earnhardt Jr. Jr. - This darling record, I confess, I've kept all to myself this year. It's my girl next door, my high school sweetheart. I thought it was simple and a little bit throwaway at first, but I kept coming back to it and all of its sweet charms. I hear Simon & Garfunkel in it and maybe some Kings of Convenience, too. They do many things so well.
Skeletons - Dale Earnhardt Jr. Jr.
4) Hurry Up, We're Dreaming, M83 - The things that make you feel alive - hold on to them. They're rare and fine, especially if they have the startling, breathless quality that Hurry Up, We're Dreaming has in droves. I was skeptical at first. A double album after so many years away? This could be a disaster or it could be amazing. Luckily, it was very much the latter. Stunning, beautiful as light.
New Map - M83
3) A Different Kind of Fix, Bombay Bicycle Club - The third studio album from British band Bombay Bicycle Club is modern indie rock at its finest. The songs are lovely and complex, full of feeling and a sense of story. Jack Steadman's voice chokes me up no matter what he's saying and I just want to listen to it forever.
Your Eyes - Bombay Bicycle Club
2) Kiss Each Other Clean, Iron & Wine - Sam Beam, no one does it like you. No one should even try. Thank you for this beautiful blessing of a record, for the birds in the trees and for grooving the summer night's away with fairy lights in the yard. For making me understand that the way things are are the way they should be.
Half Moon - Iron & Wine
1) James Blake, James Blake - When you strip all the trappings and illusions away, what you're left with is simply the truth. James Blake does this with everything he touches. There's no hiding. There's not a single extranumerary note or word in his songs and yet they contain whole worlds within them. His songs come on and I'm surrounded. Sometimes I'm drifting and sometimes I'm floating and sometimes I'm absolutely drowning. I wrote about James Blake more than twice as much as any other musician this year and I could talk about him for years to come. I can't believe this is his debut album and I can't wait to hear more from him.
A Case Of You (Joni Mitchell Cover) - James Blake